9/11: I Have Cat Remembers

It was almost 9:00am and being unemployed I was still in bed. My roommate Jen, leaving for work on that crisp sunny September morning casually suggested I turn on the TV.  “They say a small plane hit the Twin Towers,” her voice trailing off.

I must have grabbed the remote and turned to “The Today Show” because I remember staring at a well pressed Matt Lauer and Katie Couric.  If they were rattled in any way it wasn’t apparent.

Flatiron Building NYC 9/8/11 @9am

On the T.V. screen, two black towers rising up between the broadcasters’ heads against an impossibly hopeful bright blue sky.  A gash in the side of one from which a torrent of black smoke gushed forth.  I called my friend Steven and told him to turn on the T.V. For him I will always be that person who gave him that news that changed the world.

I noticed something enter frame from the corner of my eye.  It wasn’t until they announced the second tower had been hit that I realized what had occurred. Before my eyes, along with Matt, Katie, and the rest of the conscious world we watched the first tower disintegrate.  My brain didn’t have the ability to compute what my eyes were registering.  I had to get out of the apartment.  

My legs took me towards the Flatiron to an intersection I knew well.  The corner of 23rd Street and 5thAvenue was a special place for me.  It provided a vantage point from which to see both the Empire State Building and the Twin Towers with a mere turn of my head.  I had to go there now in order to prove to myself that what I had seen on TV could not be reality.

The city had come to a stop. Not a car on the street.  People walked like zombies in a trance.  The only sounds were those of sirens wailing relentlessly in our stead, never once stopping to take a breath.  It was a glorious crisp sunny fall day. The world didn’t end on days like this.

The closer I got to 5th Avenue the more I became aware off an odd smell in the air.  Like burning, but not quite.   Upon reaching the Flatiron building I made a left and found myself in the middle of the street filled with fellow New Yorkers frozen in place.

Businessmen, nannies with prams, Hasidic men in full garb, bike messengers all staring south at a single tower and next to it, its crippled twin consisting only of black smoke.  It was unclear to me if the second tower was really gone. I had to see empty space with my own eyes before I could believe it. Perhaps it was merely hidden behind a smoke curtain.

New York City, 9/10/2011

 

I’m embarrassed to admit it, but my first thought was not of the thousands of lives lost – that didn’t even enter my mind. I wondered how odd it would be to have only one Twin Tower and if they would rebuild a second one?  Before I could truly contemplate anything, the top of the second tower wobbled much in the way a mirage might in the desert.

Believing my eyes were playing tricks on me I squinted and tried harder to focus.  Reality hit us all simultaneously. A collective primal wall of sound rose from our guts directed at the crumbling tower falling layer-by-layer before our very eyes like dominos.  The sound was continuous and didn’t stop even when the inevitable was obvious.

Businessmen in pristine suits dropped their briefcases, fell to their knees and pulled their hair.  Nannies and hipsters clung to one another sobbing. Strangers offered each other working cell phones.

After that moment my memory fails me, I remember things in disconnected flashes. Lot of watching television from my couch. I felt lost but had no desire to leave the city. It wasn’t a choice, I couldn’t abandon it.

I wished there was something I could do to be of use and cursed not having an expertise of some sort that would be useful at Ground Zero. My roommate and I went to the Javitt Center to donate blood but were turned away. They had lots of blood, but no one to give it to.

That night I met friends for dinner at Les Halles, a French bistro in my neighborhood. It was packed. No one wanted to be alone. We drank, smoked, and ate in a desire to feel alive.

At night the city was enveloped in an eerie quiet–pierced intermittently with the sound of fighter jets patrolling the five boroughs.  The next morning I woke up, showered (?), dressed, and walked to Union Square – the southernmost point we were able to go – to be alone with others.

 

I bemoaned never having gone to Windows on the World or battled the crowds to the top of the towers to take in the view.  A few days ago my Mom reminded me that I had in fact been to the top of those Towers. She had the t-shirt to prove it.

We would go on, lick our wounds, learn how to defend the city, and prove to the rest of the world that no one can push around a New Yorker.  I would do anything to make sure that others would come to admire and enjoy the Freedom Tower the way my sister and I did The Twin Towers when we were little girls full of dreams.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
This entry was posted in Tamar and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • Sarah Menzies

    Wow. I can’t believe you saw the second tower crumble, in real life, with your own eyes. I cannot imagine how scary that must’ve been!
    Thinking of all you fabulous New Yorkers on this very sad day :o (
    xo

    • http://twitter.com/ihavecat I HAVE CAT

      Thank you Sarah…it wasn’t fear as much as disbelief….shock…..it was so surreal…..
      Thanks for reading and for posting a comment.
      T

  • http://fluffy-the-cat.blogspot.com/ Fluffy and Heather

    I could literally feel a sick feeling rising in my stomach as I read this blog post, especially as you described the fall of the second tower. To have been there, and watched it happen…I can’t even imagine what it would have been like. I hope and pray that NYC will never have to experience a tragedy of this magnitude ever again.

    • http://twitter.com/ihavecat I HAVE CAT

      Thank you for reading and taking the time to post your thoughts/feelings. It’s so surreal and yes it makes me ill as well. In the moment it was just disbelief…..shock…..my heart still hurts so many years later….i thought the city actually did a lovely job with the Memorial..I definitely want to visit..

  • Mzterri

    great story – thanks for sharing

    I was out of work by then too… and would remain mostly unemployed till mid 2004

    your thoughts just seem so New Yorky – and you should feel good about that

    • http://twitter.com/ihavecat I HAVE CAT

      New Yorky – i’m glad that’s a good thing :)
      Thank you for reading it and taking the time to post a comment.
      T

  • http://www.yourdailycute.com yourdailycute

    I can’t imagine what it was like watching it there. The part about having plenty of blood, but no one to give it to… wow. {{hugs}}

    • http://twitter.com/ihavecat I HAVE CAT

      I know it was such a helpless feeling……everyone waiting for the ERs to fill and nothing…..
      xo

  • Carol Furgal

    Tamar, this must have been so difficult for you to write.  As I read this, I felt your spirit woven into your words.  Thank you for allowing your story to become part of the fabric of our lives.  You eloquently describe our humanity — our ability to face the unthinkable, mourn our loss, and join with one another to survive and move forward.  Much love and peace to you today and always!

    • http://twitter.com/ihavecat I HAVE CAT

      Thanks you for your touching words. I think your comment was quite eloquent. Thank you for sharing on your page with your friends and family.
      xo
      T

  • sharon

    Thank you for sharing your memories with us.  The crumbling of the 2 towers still makes me feel ill, 10 years later.

    • http://twitter.com/ihavecat I HAVE CAT

      My mother read your comment (not realizing it was YOU sharing) and said – that’s exactly how I feel…..thanks for reading and posting Sharon. xo

  • http://www.zeezoey.com Deb Barnes – Zee and Zoey

    Tamar – For me, the image that haunts me to this day was one of a scene that looked like some sort of snow storm. The TV screen was covered in a blurry haze of shades of grey… with the glow of a red light peaking though the muted colors. In the background was the eerie and nonstop blare of what was probably dozens of car alarms that had been set off. Of course, it was not snow, it was the overwhelming cloak of smoke, dust, and rubble that was chocking every nook and cranny of the city and the red light was that of a police car, also covered in the ugly ashes.
     
    While I was not it the city like you, and cannot imagine your feelings at that very moment that you witnessed something so mind boggling, that it still does not register in my mind as being possible, I did have a co-worker who was. He called me hours after the event and because he was in law enforcement, he was smack in the middle of ground zero and clearly in shock. He just kept muttering over and over to me, “bodies… body parts… oh my God, oh my God…” I felt such pain and hopelessness at that moment and that will never go away.
     
    Thank you for your honest and heartfelt post – while it is painful to relive, I feel it is important to share our feelings on a day like this.

    • http://twitter.com/ihavecat I HAVE CAT

      OH God your poor friend….I cannot even imagine what he saw. It must haunt him to this day. There was so much we didn’t know at first – about the horror of the people jumping etc. It wasn’t spoken of for a long time. And no one to this day, who has been there, had talked about the bodies they had to step over to get away….I cannot imagine it…..

      I couldn’t turn on the TV today since I can’t take looking at the footage of what happened that day. It’s too much. I did watch part of the memorial though and thought they did a lovely job with the water fountains in the footprint of the buildings. I want to go visit soon….

      Thanks Deb, for reading and taking the time to share your thoughts.
      T
      xo
      PS – I think I will attend the Writers Conference – will let you know for sure shortly.

      • http://www.zeezoey.com Deb Barnes – Zee and Zoey

        Tamar -

        I didn’t want to turn the TV on yesterday, but I found that I just could not stop myself, thus becoming an emotional zombie for most of the day. CBS did a tribute last night through the eyes of one of the fire departments. I forget which one, but all of the firefighters survived. But, most tragically, it is now coming to light that many of the survivors have now since died at a young age, due to the toxins in the air they inhaled. And then, of course, many have been so permanantly scared emotionally, that they can no longer function in society… such a tragedy.

        The memorial was extremley moving and I agree, the fountain is just beautiful.

  • MyKinKStar

    I went up the speedy elevator once to see the city from on top of the WTC, sometime in the 80′s.  So sad though, I can only barely remember that much.  Even sadder, my then boyfriend wasn’t much for pictures, so there’s nothing to prove I was there or anything to jar a thought either.  Nothing left but my crippled memory.  Never, ever thought those buildings wouldn’t be there forever . . . 

  • http://www.timmystones.com Rebecca Slattery-Kavanagh

    I echo Deb’s sentiments – it is important to share our feelings on a day like this.  Coming from the UK we were no strangers to terrorism – but I detest the Britons who almost crow about how we’d had to deal with it (because of the IRA) for years.  It’s true, we were more used to it than the US but the IRA never did anything like this. We were familiar with the concept – but not terrorism on this scale. Working in London’s financial district at the time, we felt this deeply.  The British are, almost mockingly, known for their stiff upper lip and their attitude of “carry on, we’re British” but following 09/11 the Americans proudly displayed this attitude too.  Sure, the western world is too materialistic and perhaps we do, sometimes, lose sight of what is actually necessary and important, BUT we will not be defeated by terrorism. There are better ways…..

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=530401628 Layla Morgan Wilde

    Tamar, I’m happy you chose to share your story. After ten years, the memory feels freshly seared. A couple days before 9/11 I used the towers as a guideposts. I had just moved to the U.S. from Canada and got lost after picking up my wedding dress. It was a similar clear day and  keep looking up at them, gradually arriving to see them up close for the first and last time.

    • http://twitter.com/ihavecat I HAVE CAT

      Wow. A couple of days before. So surreal especially when you’ve just seen them in all their massiveness with your own eyes. I had a similar experience that I wrote about a while back http://ihavecat.com/2010/12/01/an-ordinary-day/
      For the longest time I couldn’t tell which way was uptown and which was downtown because I didn’t have my beacons to guide me…

  • Jmuhjacat

    Sharing your article on my social networking pages, Tamar, with thanks.  

    • http://twitter.com/ihavecat I HAVE CAT

      Thank you for sharing it. I’m glad you found it of interest. =^^=

  • Christy

    Thanks for sharing this, Tamar.  I remember it was so hard being away from NYC at this time and I felt so helpless, just wanted to drive up there.  I could hardly reach you, Lee, etc on the phone and wondered how you all were. So interesting you went to Flatiron.  I always loved that view. Today was an emotional day remembering my time there working in the Financial center having left NYC just a year earlier. It was such a beautiful area to work and live. I found old pictures when my parents had visited me and yes, I took them to Windows on the World. Next time in NYC, we will have to go visit the memorial. I never went back to ‘Ground Zero’ but I’m ready now. Thinking of you and all my NYC friends today. xx

    • http://twitter.com/ihavecat I HAVE CAT

      It’s hard for me to remember you as NOT being here on that day given you were/are such a part of my NYC experience and I think of you as being so very NYC.

      I can’t imagine, having worked down there, what it must have felt like/been for you. Thank god you were there to witness what occurred on that day Christy. I cannot imagine.

      I never got to go to Windows on The World…a regret of mine….and I don’t even think i have many photos of it that i took..i know there is one from when I crossed the Brooklyn Bridge once…..i thought I didn’t look cute in it but boy i wanna find that photo now…

      I def want to go to the memorial..i think they did a lovely job.

  • http://opcatchat.blogspot.com Caren Gittleman

    ((((hugs)))) beautifully written, (I know that it was super important to you for this to be “perfect”) Loved it. I find it so interesting (as well as sad) to read the first hand coverage from those like yourself who were actually there. It affected all of us but probably nothing like it affected all of you who were in such close proximity. It still all seems so surreal.

    • http://twitter.com/ihavecat I HAVE CAT

      Surreal is the perfect word Caren.
      Thanks for the (((hugs))) and compliment, I’m glad you found the post of interest.
      And thanks as always for your support. You are the best C. :)
      T

  • Anonymous

    Tamar, thank you for recording your memories of that day. I can’t imagine being that close to the images I saw of the Towers, especially when they each fell, and the horrible things no one talked about. But a city like New York with its heart seemingly crushed and burned, yet everyone pulled together and did their best to begin the healing right away. The real healing will take years, even generations. I tried to post when I read this first thing this morning because I wanted to comment right away, but for some reason couldn’t then, now a whole day has gone by. I hope after today with its videos and photos and stories you’re not deeply remembering that day, but can begin to forget.

    • http://twitter.com/ihavecat I HAVE CAT

      Thank you Bernadette for your eloquent words – as always. Sorry you had trouble commenting earlier in the day….
      xo

  • Milo and Alfie’s mom

    A beautiful post about a sad day that we will never forget. Thank you.

    Jan
    http://milocat.wordpress.com/

    • http://twitter.com/ihavecat I HAVE CAT

      Thank you so much Jan. xo

  • http://Freyacat.co.uk Freya, Teego & Chatzi

    What a wonderful and very moving account of the day. Something completely original amongst all the news reports that are everywhere at the moment.

    • http://twitter.com/ihavecat I HAVE CAT

      Thanks you Chris (and Freya, Teego and Chatzi!).   That means a lot :)

  • mimi

    thanks for your memories.. Hard to believe it wasn’t all a dream:(

    • http://twitter.com/ihavecat I HAVE CAT

      I know Mimi…if only it were. xo

  • http://twitter.com/KimClune Kim Clune

    The tee your mother shared is a beautiful memory: smiling, innocent faces in an unmarred span of time. It’s so moving to me to see that, and yet sad to know that that place will never hold the same magical spark for us.

    Yes, we’ve moved on, but there is no doubt we are scarred. Only the next generations can escape this new meaning. They will know, but they won’t have the ability to feel the depth of our loss. And that, I think, is a true blessing of hope. 

    There will be more smiling faces to come, like those on that shirt… untouched, unscarred and happy.

  • Bethcope

    I thought of you all day that day. Everyone in my office let out the same gutteral shriek when we saw the tower fall. We had a guest in our office from DC who could not go home.  We also did not work the next day or two and it seemed unthinkable to take your eyes off of what was happening to our fellow Americans while we were helpless and could not aid. Perhaps not physically – but we were all there with you…

  • http://prudencepup.blogspot.com/ Theresa & Prudence

    Just catching up on your blog. Great post regarding the day. I was at 6th and Prince (Butterick Bldg), not close but too close. Still dealing w/ what happened. When I think I’ve moved on, something sets a memory off. Working a few blocks from the site now doesn’t help. 

    • http://twitter.com/ihavecat I HAVE CAT

      Thank you for your comment…my apologies for taking so long to respond…..yes, that’s pretty far downtown…i’ve been meaning to go to the site but i haven’t yet..